Search for a story:

Big wait starts for SCA to decide

News - Date: 07 December 2018

Written by: Anton van Zyl / Viewed: 2760


The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) will now decide which way the Masindi Clementine Mphephu case will continue. This is the case where the daughter of the late Paramount Chief Tshimangadzo Mphephu is contesting the Vhavenda kingship/queenship. She opposes the decision to appoint Toni Mphephu Ramabulana as king of the Vhavenda and reckons she was discriminated against because of her gender.

The case served before a full bench of judges in Bloemfontein on Friday (30th). The judges were Presiding Judge Maya, along with Judges Swain, Mathopo, Mocumie and Mothle.

The case ended up with the SCA after Judge President Ephraim Makgoba ruled against Masindi Mphephu in December 2016 in the Thohoyandou High Court. He was not impressed by the arguments presented and he questioned whether the applicants had exhausted all other avenues, such as the Commission on Traditional Leadership Disputes and Claims, to resolve the dispute. He was also not convinced that the issue of male primogeniture was central to the case. Masindi’s legal team appealed his ruling.

According to Masindi’s lawyer, Mr Johann Hammann (Sr), they are very positive after Friday’s session. During such an appeal hearing, all the necessary affidavits and replies are filed beforehand. The judges scrutinize these and then have the opportunity to ask questions to the legal representatives of the appellant and the respondents.

Masindi was represented by advocate Alan Dodson (SC). The president of SA, the Minister of Co-operative Government and Traditional Affairs and the Commission on Traditional Leadership Disputes and Claims were represented by advocate N Arendse (SC). Toni Mphephu Ramabulana and the Mphephu Ramabulana Royal Council were represented by advocate IAM Semenya (SC).

Hammann said in an interview earlier this week that the judges might surprise everyone and have a verdict ready before the festive-season recess starts on 15 December. If not, they will only know the outcome early in the new year.



To leave a comment you need to login / register first

Readers are encouraged to comment on articles and express their opinion. The views expressed by readers should in no way be perceived as necessarily that of the newspaper or its staff members. Comments may be pre-moderated by our team and if found offensive, be removed.

When commenting, please respect others. Be polite to all the members of our community, including other commenters, authors and the subjects of articles. We believe strongly that the Zoutnet group of websites should be a safe and welcoming space for all individuals, groups and their ideas. As such, any rudeness, insults, hate speech, hostility, or language that incites racism or unfair discrimination may be removed and you may lose your ability to comment. 

Masindi Clementine Mphephu (left) photographed shortly after arrival at the Bloemfontein court. Photo supplied.


Johann Hamman (Sr), in the front, waits for the court proceedings to start on Friday. Behind him sits Masindi Mphephu and in the gallery behind them the various supporters. Photo supplied.

Mphephu Mbulaheni (left), Masindi Mphephu and Tracy Kulu. Photo supplied.

Julia Munyai accompanied Masindi Mphephu on Friday. Photo supplied.

Masindi Mphephu and her half-brother, Ramese Vhizani, at the court buildings last Friday. Photo supplied.

Masindi Mphephu (left) at the steps in front of the Supreme Court of Appeal in Bloemfontein. Photo supplied.

Monica Tshipuke (left) and Ramakulukusha Phumudzo (right) were with Masindi Mphephu when she arrived at the court buildings in Bloemfontein. Photo supplied.


Anton van Zyl

Anton van Zyl has been with the Zoutpansberger and Limpopo Mirror for over 27 years. He graduated at the the Rand Afrikaans University (now University of Johannesburg) and obtained a BA Communications degree. He is a founder member of the Association of Independent Publishers.


Recent Articles